By Ali Khalil, Registered Real Estate Salesperson, Royal LePage Terrequity Realty, Brokerage (Independently Owned & Operated)
If your home or investment property in the Toronto area is worth less than you paid, it can feel like you are stuck. You are not. You have choices, and the first step is to find out where you actually stand. This article walks through how to get your real numbers, what your options are and who to talk to along the way. I am a real estate salesperson, not a mortgage professional, accountant or lawyer, so please think of this as a starting point.
Is my property worth less than I paid, or less than I owe?
These are two different situations, and it helps to know which one is yours.
A property that is worth less than you paid has lost value since you bought it, but you may still have equity if your mortgage balance is lower than what the property would sell for today. A property where you owe more than it is worth is in negative equity, which means a sale would not cover your mortgage payout and the costs of selling.
Here is a hypothetical, for illustration only. It is not about any specific property. Suppose you paid $700,000 and your mortgage balance is now $620,000. If similar properties are selling near $640,000, yours is worth $60,000 less than you paid, yet it would still be worth about $20,000 more than your balance, before the costs of selling. If similar properties are selling near $600,000, you would owe about $20,000 more than the property is worth, and the costs of selling would come on top of that.
The market numbers show why owners are asking. TRREB's September 2026 Market Watch reports a GTA average selling price of $1,006,409, down 5.1% from a year earlier. The change differs by property type, from down 0.2% for semi-detached homes to down 7.7% for condo apartments (table below). An average reflects the mix of properties that sold, so only a review of recent sales near your own property can tell you what it is worth.
How do I find my real numbers?
Gather two things: a payout statement from your lender and a comparative market analysis (CMA) of your property.
The first is a payout statement from your lender. It shows your balance and what it would cost to pay off the mortgage today, including any penalty your lender may charge, so ask them to spell it out. The second is a CMA, short for comparative market analysis. It looks at recent sold prices for similar properties nearby, adjusted for size, features and condition. Sold prices matter more than asking prices, because asking prices only show what owners hope to get.
A CMA is a market comparison, not an appraisal.
Then put the numbers on one page. A net proceeds worksheet lists the likely sale price, your mortgage payout, the real estate fee, legal fees, and adjustments for property tax (and condo fees, if you own a condo). Real estate fees are negotiated between you and the brokerage and must be in writing, so compare full written agreements and not just a percentage. If you own a condo, our article on condo fees in Downtown Toronto shows what buyers will weigh when they look at your building.
What are my options if my property is worth less than I paid?
You can hold, sell, rent it out or talk to your lender about your mortgage, and each has something to check first.
| Option | What it can do | What to check first |
|---|---|---|
| Hold | Keeps your home or your plans unchanged and avoids selling at today's prices | Your monthly costs, such as mortgage, property tax, insurance, upkeep and any condo fees, plus your renewal date and how long you can comfortably wait |
| Sell | Ends the monthly costs and the mortgage | Your payout, and whether the sale price covers the costs of selling |
| Rent it out | Brings in income while you hold | Whether the rent covers your costs, any rules that apply to your property, and the tax side, which is a question for your accountant |
| Talk to your lender | May lower your payments or ease a renewal | The total cost over time, in dollars, before you agree to anything |
If you sell for less than your mortgage payout plus the costs of selling, the difference has to come from you at closing, so ask your lawyer to confirm any shortfall before you accept an offer. If you are buying another home, ask your lender whether your mortgage can move with you.
Who should I speak with first?
Start with your lender, especially if your payments are a strain.
Your lender holds the facts that decide your options: your balance, your renewal date and what they can offer. If you are falling behind, or think you might, call them before you miss a payment. From there, you can decide what to do next. A mortgage broker can compare what other lenders might offer, an accountant can explain how renting or selling affects your taxes, and a real estate lawyer can confirm any shortfall and the closing steps.
Whatever you decide, take your time and be cautious about anyone who pressures you to act quickly or to sign something before you have seen your numbers.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I sell my property if I owe more than it is worth?
Yes, but the sale price has to cover your mortgage payout and the costs of selling, or you bring the difference to closing. Ask your lender for a payout statement and ask your lawyer to confirm the shortfall before you accept any offer. If you are struggling with payments, start by talking to your lender.
Should I wait for prices to recover?
Nobody can say when or whether prices will recover. Waiting has a cost, because your mortgage payments, property tax, insurance and any condo fees continue meanwhile. Weigh the cost of waiting against your own plans and your renewal date.
How long does it take to sell a property in the GTA?
In September 2026, TRREB reported an average of 34 days on market across the GTA. That is an average for one month across all property types, and individual properties vary with price, condition and location.
When should I contact my lender?
As early as you can, ideally before you miss a payment. Your lender can explain your options before a problem grows.
Do I need an appraisal or a CMA?
A CMA helps you decide whether to hold or sell, and it is not an appraisal. Ask your lender whether it requires a formal appraisal for any change to your mortgage.
Local proof: what do the GTA numbers say right now?
TRREB's September 2026 Market Watch, released on October 6, 2026, reports 5,040 GTA sales, down 9.0% from 5,540 a year earlier, and an average selling price of $1,006,409, down 5.1% from $1,060,036. It says uncertainty surrounding the economy, inflation and borrowing costs weighed on home sales. By property type, the average prices were:
| Property type (GTA, September 2026) | Average price | Change from September 2025 |
|---|---|---|
| Detached | $1,292,016 | down 5.1% |
| Semi-detached | $1,015,202 | down 0.2% |
| Townhouse | $820,637 | down 4.6% |
| Condo apartment | $605,257 | down 7.7% |
These are figures for the whole GTA in one month, and an average price is not a benchmark price, so they describe the properties that sold and not the value of yours. For wider context, see our September 2026 GTA market update and our article on whether to buy a Toronto condo now or wait until 2027.
Want to see your real numbers?
What would help you most right now: knowing what similar properties near yours have sold for, or knowing what you would keep after a sale? If you own a house, townhouse or condo in the Toronto area, I can prepare a CMA and a net proceeds worksheet with no pressure and no obligation to list. Call 289-442-5154, email alikhalil@royallepage.ca, or visit alikhalil.ca to start a conversation.





